Second Law, Reversible and Irreversible Processes: JEE Main
Reviewed Last updated 2026-11-20. Syllabus topic: Second law, reversible and irreversible processes.
In short. No cyclic engine can turn all its absorbed heat into work, and heat does not flow from cold to hot by itself. No engine between two reservoirs beats the reversible (Carnot) engine, with efficiency 1 - T2/T1 in kelvin. Dissipative and unrestrained processes are irreversible.
- Kelvin-Planck: no cyclic device can take heat from one reservoir and convert it entirely into work. Clausius: heat cannot flow by itself from a colder to a hotter body.
- Reversible means quasi-static and free of dissipation (no friction, no finite temperature difference, no unrestrained expansion); everything else is irreversible.
- Carnot engine: efficiency = 1 - T2/T1 = W/Q1 = 1 - Q2/Q1, with temperatures in kelvin; it does not depend on the working substance.
- Refrigerator: COP = Q2/W = T2/(T1 - T2) when reversible; heat rejected to the hot reservoir is Q1 = Q2 + W.
- No engine working between the same two reservoirs can have greater efficiency than a reversible one; all reversible engines between them have the same efficiency.
- Spontaneous natural processes (free expansion, conduction across a temperature gap, Joule heating, diffusion) run one way only.
Syllabus line: Thermodynamics Thermal equilibrium and the concept of temperature, zeroth law of thermodynamics, heat, work and internal energy. The first law of thermodynamics, isothermal and adiabatic processes. The second law of thermodynamics: reversible and irreversible processes. (NTA JEE (Main) 2026 syllabus, Physics, Unit 8 (https://jeemain.nta.nic.in/document/syllabus-2026/))
Before you start
Prerequisites
- First law, isothermal and adiabatic processes: The Carnot cycle is built from two isotherms and two adiabats. Read this first if heat and work in those processes are unclear.
- Temperature, zeroth law, heat, work and internal energy: Cycle work as an enclosed area and the kelvin scale are needed. Read this first if a clockwise loop or the offset 273 is unclear.
Related topics
- Thermodynamics (lesson planned)
- First law, isothermal and adiabatic processes
- Temperature, zeroth law, heat, work and internal energy
- Kinetic Theory of Gases (lesson planned)
The concept step by step
Why a second law is needed
The first law only counts energy, and it would allow a ship to run by cooling the sea or a cup of tea to heat up by drawing heat from the cooler air. Nature never does these. The second law records the direction of natural processes. Two equivalent statements: Kelvin-Planck (no cyclic engine converts heat from a single reservoir entirely into work) and Clausius (no cyclic device moves heat from a cold body to a hot body with no other effect).
Heat engines and efficiency
A heat engine takes heat Q1 from a hot reservoir at T1, does work W and rejects heat Q2 to a cold reservoir at T2 in each cycle. Over a complete cycle dU = 0, so W = Q1 - Q2. The efficiency is the fraction of absorbed heat that is turned into work: efficiency = W/Q1 = 1 - Q2/Q1. By the Kelvin-Planck statement, Q2 cannot be zero, so efficiency is always below 1.
Reversible processes and the Carnot engine
A process is reversible if it can be run backwards through the same states with no net change anywhere else. That needs quasi-static steps and no dissipation. The Carnot cycle has four steps: isothermal expansion at T1, adiabatic expansion down to T2, isothermal compression at T2, adiabatic compression back to T1. For it Q2/Q1 = T2/T1, so efficiency = 1 - T2/T1 with temperatures in kelvin. It is the maximum possible between two given reservoirs and is independent of the working substance.
Refrigerators and heat pumps
A refrigerator is an engine run in reverse: work W is supplied, heat Q2 is taken from the cold space at T2 and Q1 = Q2 + W is rejected to the room at T1. Its coefficient of performance is COP = Q2/W, and for a reversible one COP = T2/(T1 - T2). A smaller temperature gap gives a much larger COP. The COP can exceed 1, so it is not an efficiency, and the heat dumped into the room always exceeds the heat removed from the inside.
Irreversible processes
Real processes are irreversible because of friction and other dissipation, heat flow across a finite temperature difference, unrestrained expansion (free expansion), mixing and diffusion, and sudden changes of pressure. After an irreversible process the system and surroundings cannot both be restored. This is why the efficiency of any real engine is lower than the Carnot value between the same temperatures; reversible processes are limits approached by making changes very slowly and by removing friction.
Worked examples
Each solution shows the marks every step would earn. The sanity check tests units and size of the answer.
Example 1 (easy)
A Carnot engine works between a source at 600 K and a sink at 300 K. Find its efficiency as a percentage.
| Step | Marks |
|---|---|
| Efficiency = 1 - T2/T1. | 1 |
| 1 - 300/600 = 0.50. | 1 |
| Efficiency = 50 percent. | 1 |
| Total: 3 marks | 3 |
Answer: 50 percent
Fast method: The sink is half the source temperature, so half the heat is rejected and half becomes work.
Sanity check: Units: none (fraction). The value lies between 0 and 1, and both temperatures are in kelvin. The efficiency would rise if the sink were colder, as the formula says.
Example 2 (easy)
A heat engine has efficiency 25 percent and does 500 J of work per cycle. Find the heat rejected to the sink per cycle in joule.
| Step | Marks |
|---|---|
| Q1 = W/efficiency = 500/0.25 = 2000 J. | 1 |
| Q2 = Q1 - W = 2000 - 500. | 1 |
| Q2 = 1500 J. | 1 |
| Total: 3 marks | 3 |
Answer: 1500 J
Fast method: Work is a quarter of Q1 so rejected heat is three quarters: 3 x 500 = 1500 J.
Sanity check: Units: J. Energy in 2000 J equals work 500 J plus rejected 1500 J. The rejected heat exceeds the work, as expected for an efficiency below 50 percent.
Example 3 (medium)
A Carnot engine works between 127 degrees C and 27 degrees C. Find the efficiency as a percentage.
| Step | Marks |
|---|---|
| Convert to kelvin: T1 = 127 + 273 = 400 K, T2 = 27 + 273 = 300 K. | 1 |
| Efficiency = 1 - T2/T1 = 1 - 300/400. | 1 |
| Efficiency = 0.25 = 25 percent. | 1 |
| Total: 3 marks | 3 |
Answer: 25 percent
Fast method: Temperature difference 100 K over the source temperature 400 K = 0.25.
Sanity check: Units: none. The efficiency is a fraction below 1. Using Celsius numbers gives 1 - 27/127 = 0.79, which is far too high for such a small temperature gap, so the check exposes the slip.
Example 4 (medium)
A reversible refrigerator keeps its inside at -13 degrees C while the room is at 27 degrees C. Find its coefficient of performance, and the work needed in kJ to remove 13 kJ of heat from the inside.
| Step | Marks |
|---|---|
| T2 = 260 K (inside) and T1 = 300 K (room). | 1 |
| COP = T2/(T1 - T2) = 260/40 = 6.5. | 1 |
| W = Q2/COP = 13/6.5. | 1 |
| W = 2.0 kJ. | 1 |
| Total: 4 marks | 4 |
Answer: COP = 6.5; W = 2.0 kJ
Fast method: COP = 260/40 = 6.5, so each kJ of work moves 6.5 kJ of heat: 13/6.5 = 2.
Sanity check: Units: kJ. Heat rejected to the room is 13 + 2 = 15 kJ, and 15/13 = 300/260 = T1/T2, the Carnot heat ratio, which confirms the numbers.
Example 5 (hard, multi-step)
The efficiency of a Carnot engine is 20 percent. When the source temperature is raised by 100 K (the sink is unchanged) the efficiency becomes one third. Find the sink temperature in kelvin.
| Step | Marks |
|---|---|
| Initially 1 - T2/T1 = 0.20, so T2 = 0.8 T1. | 1 |
| Afterwards 1 - T2/(T1 + 100) = 1/3, so T2 = (2/3)(T1 + 100). | 1 |
| Equate: 0.8 T1 = (2/3)(T1 + 100), so 2.4 T1 = 2 T1 + 200 and T1 = 500 K. | 2 |
| T2 = 0.8 x 500 = 400 K. | 1 |
| Total: 5 marks | 5 |
Answer: 400 K (source initially 500 K)
Fast method: Sink = 0.8 T1 = (2/3)(T1 + 100). Solve: T1 = 500 K, so T2 = 400 K.
Sanity check: Units: K. Check: 1 - 400/500 = 0.20 and 1 - 400/600 = 0.333, matching both statements. The sink temperature stays below the source in both cases.
Example 6 (hard, multi-step)
An inventor claims an engine working between 400 K and 300 K that absorbs 1000 J per cycle and delivers 300 J of work. Decide whether the claim is possible, and find the maximum work in joule that any engine could deliver.
| Step | Marks |
|---|---|
| The Carnot efficiency between 400 K and 300 K is 1 - 300/400 = 0.25. | 1 |
| The claimed efficiency is 300/1000 = 0.30, which exceeds 0.25. | 2 |
| An efficiency greater than the Carnot value violates the second law, so the claim is impossible. | 1 |
| The maximum work is 0.25 x 1000 = 250 J. | 1 |
| Total: 5 marks | 5 |
Answer: Impossible; the maximum work is 250 J
Fast method: Compute the Carnot limit first: 25 percent of 1000 J is 250 J, so 300 J is not allowed.
Sanity check: Units: J. The minimum heat rejected is 1000 - 250 = 750 J, which equals 1000 x 300/400, the Carnot ratio. The claimed 700 J of rejection would be below that limit.
Formulas and units
| Result | Formula | Valid when | Units or note | Worked example |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engine and work | W = Q1 - Q2 per cycle | heat engine over one complete cycle | J | Example 2 |
| Efficiency | efficiency = W/Q1 = 1 - Q2/Q1 | heat engine over one complete cycle | dimensionless | Example 2 |
| Carnot efficiency | efficiency = 1 - T2/T1 (kelvin) | reversible (Carnot) engine between two reservoirs; T in kelvin | dimensionless | Example 1 |
| Carnot heat ratio | Q2/Q1 = T2/T1 | reversible (Carnot) cycle between two reservoirs; T in kelvin | dimensionless | none |
| Refrigerator COP | COP = Q2/W = Q2/(Q1 - Q2) | refrigerator over one complete cycle; Q2 from the cold space | dimensionless | Example 4 |
| Reversible refrigerator | COP = T2/(T1 - T2) | reversible refrigerator between two reservoirs; T in kelvin | dimensionless | Example 4 |
| Heat pump (heating) COP | Q1/W = T1/(T1 - T2) = COP_refrigerator + 1 | reversible heat pump between two reservoirs; T in kelvin | dimensionless | none |
| Engine and refrigerator link | COP = (1 - efficiency)/efficiency, same reservoirs | refrigerator is the same cycle as the engine run in reverse | dimensionless | none |
| Kelvin-Planck | no cyclic engine converts heat from one reservoir entirely into work | not applicable | n/a (statement) | none |
| Clausius | no cyclic device moves heat cold to hot with no other effect | not applicable | n/a (statement) | none |
Common mistakes and speed
- Using Celsius temperatures in the Carnot efficiency or COP. Why it tempts: The data are given in degrees C and the formula looks like a simple ratio; only the kelvin scale works.
- Quoting the heat rejected to the room as the heat removed from the refrigerator. Why it tempts: Q1 and Q2 sound alike and the wrong value, Q2 + W, is a given option.
- Treating a slow process as reversible even when friction acts. Why it tempts: Quasi-static and reversible are often taught together, but reversibility also needs the absence of dissipation.
- Thinking an isothermal expansion violates the Kelvin-Planck statement because heat turns entirely into work. Why it tempts: The statement forbids this in a complete cycle with no other effect; an isothermal expansion leaves the gas in a different state.
- Writing the COP of a refrigerator as 1 - T2/T1 or capping it at 1. Why it tempts: It is called an efficiency in everyday talk; the COP is a ratio of heat removed to work and is often greater than 1.
- Assuming efficiency changes equally for raising the source and lowering the sink by the same dT. Why it tempts: Both change the temperature difference by dT, but the sink change gives dT/T1 while the source change gives dT T2/T1², which is smaller.
Time per question and fast method
Target: about 90 seconds per question.
Convert to kelvin first. Engine: efficiency = (T1 - T2)/T1 and Q2/Q1 = T2/T1. Refrigerator: COP = T2/(T1 - T2) and Q1 = Q2 + W. For classification questions look for friction, a finite temperature gap and unrestrained expansion: any one of them makes the process irreversible.
Recall quiz
Pick an option for each question. Your answers stay on this page and are not sent anywhere.
Score: 0 of 6 correct. Pick an option for each question.
Practice
- A Carnot engine works between a source at 227 degrees C and a sink at 27 degrees C. In each cycle it absorbs… Verified (T1)
- An ideal reversible refrigerator keeps its inside at -3 degrees C while the room is at 27 degrees C. For 2.0… Verified (T1)
- Consider these six processes: (a) free expansion of a gas into an evacuated container; (b) quasi-static… Verified (T1)
- Two Carnot engines are coupled in series. The first takes 2400 J per cycle from a source at 900 K and rejects… Verified (T3)
Previous-year questions
Previous-year questions are not imported yet. Previous-year questions are not imported yet; see the official papers on the NTA site. Official NTA papers page.
Going deeper and revision
Statements of the second law and their equivalence
Kelvin-Planck: it is impossible to construct a device that operates in a cycle and produces no effect other than the extraction of heat from one reservoir and its complete conversion into work. Clausius: it is impossible for a cyclic device to transfer heat from a colder to a hotter body with no other effect. The two statements are equivalent: a violation of one allows the other to be built. The word 'cycle' matters: an isothermal expansion of a gas turns heat entirely into work, but it is not a cycle and leaves the gas in a new state. Refrigerators do move heat from cold to hot, but only because work is supplied.
Reversible and irreversible processes: a checklist
For reversibility test three things: the change must be quasi-static (infinitely slow, system always in equilibrium); there must be no friction, viscosity, electrical resistance or other dissipation; and any heat transfer must be across an infinitesimal temperature difference. Irreversible examples: free expansion, conduction between bodies at finite temperature difference, Joule heating, diffusion and mixing of different gases, sudden bursting of a balloon, an inelastic collision. Quasi-static, frictionless isothermal and adiabatic changes are idealised reversible. A quasi-static process with friction is not reversible: slowness alone is not sufficient.
Carnot engine and efficiency results
Efficiency = 1 - T2/T1 (kelvin). Raising the source temperature or lowering the sink temperature raises it; lowering the sink by the same amount helps more than raising the source by that amount, because the efficiency changes by dT/T1 against dT T2/T1². Q2/Q1 = T2/T1 and W = Q1 (T1 - T2)/T1. No real engine between the same reservoirs can beat it, and an engine that claims to do so is impossible (a violation of the second law). Two Carnot engines in series between T1 and T3 behave as one engine between T1 and T3; the intermediate temperature cancels in the overall heat ratio. Carnot efficiency is 100 percent only at T2 = 0 K, which cannot be reached.
Refrigerator, heat pump and the coefficient of performance
COP of a refrigerator = Q2/W = Q2/(Q1 - Q2); reversible: T2/(T1 - T2). Relation with the engine efficiency: COP = (1 - efficiency)/efficiency for the same reservoirs. A heat pump (heating the room) has COP_heating = Q1/W = T1/(T1 - T2), which is COP_refrigerator + 1. Typical errors: using Celsius temperatures, confusing Q1 and Q2, and quoting heat rejected when the question asks for heat removed. If temperatures are given in degrees C, convert first: -3 degrees C and 27 degrees C are 270 K and 300 K, giving a COP of 9.
What examiners test and edge cases
Frequent forms: efficiency of a Carnot engine from Celsius data and work from absorbed heat; change in efficiency when source or sink temperature changes by a given amount; checking whether a claimed engine or refrigerator is possible; COP and heat removed for a given work; Carnot engines in series with equal work or equal efficiency; classifying a list of processes as reversible or irreversible (count them). Edge cases: an isothermal expansion is not a cyclic conversion; a quasi-static process with friction is irreversible; the engine efficiency formula needs reservoirs, not a variable-temperature source. Entropy as a quantity is not named in this syllabus line; you only need the direction statements.
Memory hook
Suppose a family drops a hot steel tumbler of tea into a bucket of cool water at the same time that a ceiling fan blades keep turning after the switch is off, slowly stopping because of friction in the bearing.
- The tea tumbler cools and the bucket warms until both reach one temperature. You never see the bucket cool by itself and heat the tumbler back up.
- The fan blades slow down and the bearing warms slightly. The warm bearing never gathers its heat back to spin the fan up again.
- Both events run in one direction only, through a finite temperature gap or through friction. Only an infinitely slow, frictionless change could be run backwards.
Heat flow across a finite temperature gap and friction are irreversible; only quasi-static, dissipation-free changes are reversible, and no engine can beat the reversible one.
Heat runs downhill by itself; going uphill costs work.
Revision card
Try to answer each without looking above.
- State the Kelvin-Planck and Clausius forms of the second law.
- Write the efficiency of a heat engine in terms of Q1 and Q2, and of a Carnot engine in terms of T1 and T2.
- List the steps of the Carnot cycle.
- Write the COP of a refrigerator and of a reversible refrigerator, and the heat rejected to the room.
- Give the conditions for a process to be reversible and three examples of irreversible processes.
- How do you test whether a claimed engine or refrigerator is possible?
Sources and review
Reviewed Reviewed on 2026-11-20: every number recomputed by code and independently reviewed; textbook section references pending.
- Method: Every number in worked examples, recall checks and notes recomputed by code; claims recomputed independently by a separate verifier run using other numerical methods; textbook section references not yet attached; wording defects found were fixed afterwards and re-linted (code checks re-run) but not re-reviewed by a second run; syllabus scope compared with the NTA JEE Main 2026 syllabus text (by the verifier; see the report)
- Reviewer: independent verifier agent run (not the author)
- Date: 2026-11-20
- Defects found: 0; fixed: 0
- Report: content/reviews/learn5-thd-2026-11-20.md
Textbook references
- NCERT Physics Part 2, Class 11 (reprint 2026-27), Chapter 11: Thermodynamics, 11.11 Carnot engine (read 2026-11-22)
- NCERT Physics Part 2, Class 11 (reprint 2026-27), Chapter 11: Thermodynamics, Summary SUMMARY (read 2026-11-22)
- NCERT Physics Part 2, Class 11 (reprint 2026-27), Chapter 11: Thermodynamics, 11.9 Second law of thermodynamics (read 2026-11-22)
- NCERT Physics Part 2, Class 11 (reprint 2026-27), Chapter 11: Thermodynamics, 11.10 Reversible and irreversible processes (read 2026-11-22)
Sources used
- Syllabus: NTA JEE (Main) 2026 syllabus, Physics, Unit 8 (https://jeemain.nta.nic.in/document/syllabus-2026/), imported into syllabus/lines/jee-main/2026.json
- Standard results of school-level thermodynamics; no textbook section reference attached yet (to be sourced at verification). Content written fresh for this site.
How labels work: see how answers and lessons are verified. Found a mistake? Use Report an error on any question page.