Consider these six processes: (a) free expansion of a gas into an evacuated container; (b) quasi-static isothermal compression of a gas by a frictionless piston, with the surroundings at the same temperature as the gas apart from an infinitesimal difference; (c) conduction of heat through a rod joining two bodies at different finite temperatures; (d) quasi-static adiabatic compression of a gas by a frictionless piston in an insulated cylinder; (e) heating of a resistor by an electric current; (f) mixing of two different gases by diffusion. The number of these processes that are irreversible is
Answer: (C) 4 Status: Verified (T1). Checked by code and independent solves on 2026-11-20.
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
Solution
- A process is reversible only if it is quasi-static and has no dissipation (no friction, no heat flow across a finite temperature difference, no unrestrained expansion).
- (b) and (d) satisfy both conditions: they are the idealised reversible processes.
- (a) unrestrained expansion, (c) finite temperature difference, (e) Joule heating and (f) diffusive mixing are irreversible. The count is 4.
Fast method
Look for the three signatures of irreversibility: unrestrained expansion, finite temperature difference, and dissipation by friction or resistance. (a), (c), (e) match them, and diffusion (f) is a spontaneous mixing that does not run backwards. Only the two quasi-static, frictionless cases are reversible.
Expected time: about 100 seconds. Difficulty: hard.
Topic page: Second law, reversible and irreversible processes