EngineeringRise

Consider these six processes: (a) free expansion of a gas into an evacuated container; (b) quasi-static isothermal compression of a gas by a frictionless piston, with the surroundings at the same temperature as the gas apart from an infinitesimal difference; (c) conduction of heat through a rod joining two bodies at different finite temperatures; (d) quasi-static adiabatic compression of a gas by a frictionless piston in an insulated cylinder; (e) heating of a resistor by an electric current; (f) mixing of two different gases by diffusion. The number of these processes that are irreversible is

Answer: (C) 4 Status: Verified (T1). Checked by code and independent solves on 2026-11-20.

  1. 2
  2. 3
  3. 4
  4. 5

Solution

  1. A process is reversible only if it is quasi-static and has no dissipation (no friction, no heat flow across a finite temperature difference, no unrestrained expansion).
  2. (b) and (d) satisfy both conditions: they are the idealised reversible processes.
  3. (a) unrestrained expansion, (c) finite temperature difference, (e) Joule heating and (f) diffusive mixing are irreversible. The count is 4.

Fast method

Look for the three signatures of irreversibility: unrestrained expansion, finite temperature difference, and dissipation by friction or resistance. (a), (c), (e) match them, and diffusion (f) is a spontaneous mixing that does not run backwards. Only the two quasi-static, frictionless cases are reversible.

Expected time: about 100 seconds. Difficulty: hard.

Topic page: Second law, reversible and irreversible processes

Test your answers now

Report an error

Think the question, answer or a step is wrong? One tap tells us. We check it and publish the correction.