An ether solution contains benzoic acid, phenol and naphthalene. The solution is shaken with aqueous sodium hydrogencarbonate and the layers are separated. The substance(s) transferred into the aqueous layer is (are)
Answer: (C) benzoic acid only Status: Verified (T1). Checked by code and independent solves on 2026-11-20.
- benzoic acid and phenol
- phenol only
- benzoic acid only
- all three
Solution
- Hydrogencarbonate removes a proton only from an acid stronger than carbonic acid.
- Benzoic acid, a carboxylic acid, is stronger than carbonic acid, so it forms sodium benzoate, which is ionic and moves into the water.
- Phenol is weaker than carbonic acid, so it stays un-ionised in the ether; naphthalene is neutral and non-polar and also stays in the ether.
- Only benzoic acid is transferred.
Fast method
Hydrogencarbonate takes carboxylic acids but not phenols: only benzoic acid is extracted.
Expected time: about 75 seconds. Difficulty: medium.
Topic page: Purification techniques