EngineeringRise

From the species Cl, P3-, S2-, Cl-, K+, Ca2+, Sc3+, Ti4+, Mg2+ and Ar (atomic numbers: Mg 12, P 15, S 16, Cl 17, Ar 18, K 19, Ca 20, Sc 21, Ti 22), let X be the number of species in this list, counting Ar itself, that are isoelectronic with Ar, and let Y be the atomic number of the ion with the largest ionic radius among those ions that are isoelectronic with Ar. The value of X + Y is

Answer: 23 Status: Verified (T3). Checked by code and independent solves on 2026-11-20.

Solution

  1. Electron count = Z minus charge. 18 electrons: P3- (15 + 3), S2-, Cl-, K+, Ca2+, Sc3+, Ti4+ and Ar itself: X = 8. Cl has 17 and Mg2+ has 10.
  2. Among the ions (Ar is a neutral atom and is excluded from the comparison) the radius falls as Z rises, so P3- (Z = 15) is the largest: Y = 15.
  3. X + Y = 8 + 15 = 23.

Fast method

Count species with 18 electrons (8, counting Ar); the largest ion is the one with the fewest protons, P3-, Z = 15; sum 23.

Expected time: about 120 seconds. Difficulty: hard.

Topic page: Periodic trends: radii, ionisation enthalpy, electron gain enthalpy, valence and oxidation states

Test your answers now

Report an error

Think the question, answer or a step is wrong? One tap tells us. We check it and publish the correction.