Metallic radii (in pm) of the 3d series: Sc 164, Ti 147, V 135, Cr 129, Mn 137, Fe 126, Co 125, Ni 125, Cu 128, Zn 137. Which statement agrees with these data?
Answer: (D) The radii of Fe, Co and Ni differ from one another by at most 1 pm. Status: Verified (T1). Checked by code and independent solves on 2026-11-20.
- The radius decreases steadily from Sc to Zn.
- Mn has a smaller radius than Cr.
- Zn has a smaller radius than Cu.
- The radii of Fe, Co and Ni differ from one another by at most 1 pm.
Solution
- Statement A fails because Mn (137) is larger than Cr (129): the trend reverses in the middle of the series.
- Statement C fails for the same pair; statement D fails because Zn (137) exceeds Cu (128).
- Fe 126, Co 125 and Ni 125 span 1 pm, so statement B is correct.
- Reason: across the 3d series the nuclear charge rises while the added 3d electrons shield the 4s electrons almost equally, so the radius changes slowly; it flattens at Fe, Co, Ni, and rises again for Zn where 3d10 repulsion is greatest.
Fast method
Scan the table for the anomalies: Mn and Zn are above their left neighbours, and Fe, Co, Ni are nearly equal.
Expected time: about 90 seconds. Difficulty: medium.