Consider the carbocations (P) (CH3)2CH+, (Q) CH3+, (R) (CH3)3C+ and (S) CH3CH2+. The order of decreasing stability is
Answer: (A) R > P > S > Q Status: Verified (T1). Checked by code and independent solves on 2026-11-20.
- R > P > S > Q
- P > R > S > Q
- Q > S > P > R
- R > S > P > Q
Solution
- Alkyl groups stabilise the positive carbon by the +I effect and by hyperconjugation with alpha C-H bonds.
- Alpha hydrogens: tert-butyl 9, isopropyl 6, ethyl 3, methyl 0.
- Stability follows the same order: R > P > S > Q.
Fast method
Tertiary > secondary > primary > methyl.
Expected time: about 60 seconds. Difficulty: easy.
Topic page: Bond fission, reaction intermediates, electronic effects and types of reactions